Search results

Use the resources outlined here to supplement: FAQ: C++ for Financial Engineering Online Course

Your fate is in your own hands :)

The EC is rarely earned; it goes to students who have, throughout their duration in the course, really established a 'forum presence'. Asking, answering others, and generally contributing to the course. The determination is subjective, and will be determined by a review of your posts after you...

The real paradigm shifts were C++11 and then C++20. It's unlikely there will be another such shift for a long time.

You should not use chat gpt for anything other than potentially getting conceptual explanations; that said, I still believe you'd be better served asking questions on this forum where you'll get answers based on real world experience, which is not always the same as the 'theoretical' answer...

Here is an excerpt from the Python course faq:

Yes

Please see https://quantnet.com/threads/instruction-on-homework-submission.7658/#post-72479

Please post this under the course forum where we're happy to help guide you. This is a general computing forum, not course related.

Yes, reach out privately for that

Exceeds 70, not 60

Yes, it should be possible given intense focus during that timeframe

Absolutely

Sounds like it's a quick overview as part of a larger course, but not necessarily in depth.

You'll need to whitelist

Q for Mortals and Q Tips are the two most popular books in the arena.

Yes, see Account upgrades

Great to see

It's something we've considered, possibly at some point. FD is the parent company of Kx, which owns kdb

Enroll will start your course immediately. Register is to pre Register for a future date; it's informal and you'll still need to enroll on that that. @Andy Nguyen, can you make this more clear on the course page?

Any questions on the course (or in general), don't hesitate to ask me here or through private message.

Learning to code requires not merely understanding of syntax (which is what a book will give you), but hands-on experience and detailed feedback/reviews on your code. Python for Finance with Intro to Data Science is a great resource to learn Python, in a finance and data-centric way, utilizing...

All solid points and great things to think about. My two cents on a few of these: It is not uncommon to see legacy libraries in C++03 + Boost, with new development in the system deliberately staying in 03. Migration of a large system is very costly. The classics will always be popular and...

@Llama , We really appreciate the feedback and review. There are definitely improvements/updates to be made on the content; the majority of typos etc. have been fixed over the years; any time a student raises we fix them. The lectures and notes style may suit some and may not suit others; while...

I've seen the gamut. There is a lot of legacy code and styles tend to be sticky in code bases.

@Andy Nguyen

The first QN C++ course instills the following: -- Proficiency in OOO, inheritance, polymorphism. -- Proficiency in generic programming (C++ templates). -- Deep understanding of C/C++ memory management (dynamic allocation), pointers, references, memory leaks, etc. -- Understanding of the...

No, see https://quantnet.com/threads/c-course-grading-policy.7768/

Yes, Bimaps are covered.

It's self paced, with TAs always available to provide real time guidance on the course forum and detailed code reviews.

This is not correct; in practice, Python will always be used to supplement a hard programming language such as C++, Java, C#. Every major firm uses multiple hard and soft languages, playing each to its core strength. C++ as a hard language is making a major comeback in many firms. C# was mostly...

@Andy Nguyen , anything we can improve there?

There is a link to the syllabus here: C++ Programming for Financial Engineering

In addition to the material, you will be getting commercially grounded, detailed guidance and feedback on all your code. As Dr. Duffy mentioned, this is far more important than reading books or watching videos. Writing good code is an art, which is only picked up through practice and guidance.

Everyone is different, but completing in 2 months is very doable if you put in a few hours per day on average

Within a few days, yes

A good C++ developer can easily learn Java, the same cannot be said the other way around. It's also worth noting that there is actually a resurgence of C++ in many firms. Java and C# were a fad that did not work out as many intended.

Correct

Your time expires at 11:59pm NY on the day that your time expires. So it's today+dayLeft until 11:59pm NY

auto rows = std::make_shared<std::unordered_set<char>>(std::unordered_set<char>[])(N) ^^something like this

It looks like you are trying to create a set of sets. The equivalent to your Java code would be a dynamic array of sets. I.e., using new with a shared_ptr.

unordered_set is the closest structure. What code did you try for that?

HWs are graded within 24-48 hours of submission. Usually much quicker, very rarely slower. You should receive you feedback/ grade by today

@Andy Nguyen

This is extremely common in the field, unfortunately. It's not only annoying, but creates significant hidden, operational risk for companies because the person tasked to productionize the code mess is not the same person who did the research, and disconnects often occur between the two. The QN...

In practice, that will be more difficult

@Andy Nguyen

Former students have access to all the material. The new material has been seamlessly incorporated into the old. You will find the new videos in several levels (their titles indicate that they are C++17/20 related): Level 1: Intro and Language Features Level 2: Language Features and Data...

Delete that

I can see merits to both approaches -- you may find the following threads useful in helping you decide: See Recommendation on QN courses https://quantnet.com/threads/recommendation-on-qn-courses.46100/post-278449 https://quantnet.com/threads/faq-python-online-course.43992/post-268609

To your analogy, jumping into the advanced course without solid underlying skills is like trying to drive an 18-wheeler truck with a learners permit to drive a car (having taken a written driving test but have not yet put in any practice hours). My recommendation would be to do both: You can...

In general, the first C++ course is required to be taken first, unless one has C++ industry experience. The first course actually goes fairly deep, and instills proper coding skills and practices that one does not pick up being self-taught or even university-taught; experience that comes with...

This will result in an infinite loop, as the input is only occurring one time, prior to the loop.

Hi, see FAQ: C++ for Financial Engineering Online Course

Much of the early-on material is ad-hoc -- they are meant to force one to think about the basic syntax. The lectures cover the concepts but the trivial syntax (i.e. how to use printf) is meant to explore and implement independently. Levels 1&2 are a lot of information, with loose connection...

In regards to the Advanced course, the prerequisites are as follows: Proficiency in OOO, inheritance, polymorphism. Proficiency in generic programming (C++ templates). Deep understanding of C/C++ memory management (dynamic allocation), pointers, references, memory leaks, etc. Understanding of...

You should not. Note that VS code is not VS

There is no option to repeat the exam. The exam is 25% of the overall grade, so it is very rare for a student to submit good work throughout the course, but fail the course due to the exam. Homeworks yes, quizzes no. The quizzes are meant as a learning tool, and can be taken any number of...

All levels are here: C++ Programming for Financial Engineering When you pass quiz 1,level 2 automatically unlocks

Hi, there is no final exam

While I mostly concur with your points here, there is a matter of semantics. Quant work does not need to be narrowly defined within the confines of derivative pricing. While derivative pricing (and related topics) are a major component of MFE programs, not many quants actively work on derivative...

eTrading roles are closer to Strat than pure Quant. Some banks have 'Straders' who do everything from build the models, do the data analysis, and actually run the book (trade), while others split this into distinct roles: Quants/Strats who work side by side with the book runners (traders). The...

Do you have VS installed?

You may find this post helpful in making that decision: FAQ: Python Online Course

I've seen is under Certifications, which can be a subsection under Education. You can put the course title, basic course description, and date earned. Additionally, put C++ under Skills

Yes

There are hidden files/folders as well that need to be deleted. See above and https://quantnet.com/threads/hw-size.44052/post-268848

You need to delete all the extra files and folders, per the submission instructions, including hidden folders. The resulting zip file should be in the low kb

Yes

All HWs, quizzes, and Skype final exam

The sln file is simply the solution file; it has nothing to do with the code. We also have the project file (.vcproj). These keep track of the code files within the project. There is never a need to directly modify those; when you add/remove code files from your project they will automatically...

Code must be part of a project to run it. Correct

Correct

The final exam is only 25% of your overall grade. Even if you failed the exam, as long as your exercise code has been good, you can still pass the course. There have been very few students who have made it to the exam and failed the course. The course's focus is on learning to write good code --...

One of the great things about Python is that it can be used in practice, to some extent, with only limited knowledge of the language. This benefit can also be a major drawback though, as there are many 'superficial' Python coders out there, writing inefficient and unmaintainable code. What was...

Yes, the course is quite comprehensive in topics, and as you progress beyond level 1, it has some very practical 'toy' exercises and a case study to solidify your knowledge. There are also documents called 'Tips, Tricks, & Pitfalls' provided with each level, that contain useful pointers of...

This will be a brand-new offering on QN, coming very soon. The details of the course (including syllabus, faq, and pre-register form) are here: Python for Finance with Intro to Data Science The course teaches Python from the ground up; it takes a very practical approach to learning while...

Yes; the rule of thumb is to delete everything besides your code files and project files (sln, vcproj, vcxproj)

Yes, delete that folder

Keep them No

Many students have used xcode or other compilers successfully. It may be a bit more work to port over code.

Yes, you can either use xcode or use a VM

1) It's a really good IDE 2) A lot of the sample code is provided as VS projects 3) IDE-specific support is in VS, not others

VS is strongly recommended, but you may use any

When you pass quiz 1, level 2 becomes available. I believe you should be able to access up to level 2 without purchasing

The zip filename should contain your real full name

Solutions are not provided, but you may always resubmit for further feedback.

While a large number of students who take the course are indeed hoping to enter MFE, we have also had many students take the course with no MFE aspirations at all. The first eight levels, which are the core of the course, are pure C/C++ without any application specific to MFE. The last level is...

Any compiler is allowed for this course, as long as your code is well-formatted and standard code. The only caveat is that parts of level 9 may be tough to do without VS.

1) Yes, many students have completed in less than 16 weeks. 2) There are time limits, but you have unlimited tries. 3) Correct

Yes, you should see all available levels here: C++ Programming for Financial Engineering You will only see level 2 once you pass quiz 1 (www.quantnet.com/quiz)

There are likely hidden files/folders that need deleting

5 points, not 10. This has nothing to do with the 'reaction score'. See https://quantnet.com/threads/c-course-grading-policy.7768/

You need to create a project, and run your code from there

VS cannot return on mac without a VM

Absolutely; the first course teaches C++ from the ground up, and puts a lot of effort into instilling good/marketable coding habits. The advanced course takes those skills to the cutting edge. There is currently a $300 discount on the advanced course for alums of the first. 16 weeks from the...

Many students have successfully used xcode on mac. For levels 1-7, xcode should be no problem at all. Levels 8&9 may be more difficult, and you can switch to a PC fit those two levels. Xcode is free

VS is strongly recommended (on a pc)

Everything besides C++ :)

At the moment, VS does not seem to offer C++ in its Mac version

I use TechSmith Camtasia | Screen Recorder & Video Editor for all in one recording, editing. A good Mic is probably more important than the software

You can try disabling intellisense : C++ IntelliSense - Visual Studio

Yes, many students have successfully completed using a Mac. Can either use xcode on mac, or set up a VM

There is an extension option here: https://quantnet.com/account/upgrades

Correct

No, it's a fresh 16 weeks, as long as the reason for retaking is time and not a failing grade

It's also worth mentioning that university courses which have a major focus on best practices (industry and in general) are few and far between. They tend to be very academic with little in the way of learning the 'art' of coding. The QN C++ certificate offers a very practical approach to...

You may find this a useful read: How Quantnet's C++ certificates got me a job on Wall Street

These are an interesting read

It's always one of the top sticky threads, labeled HW. Should not be difficult to find

See the second to top thread in the level 2 forum...

Fixed

Thanks for raising this; it'll be updated shortly

The entire course is doable on Windows, Mac, or Linux. PyCharm has a version for Mac (and Linux), and there is no course dependency on Windows.

This looks to me like a project structure issue; missing #includes, incorrect additional include directories, and/or incorrect/missing files being linked as part of the project. Are you using a provided project (similar to the one provided to your during QN C++) or creating your own project...

What is the exact error you see?

See https://quantnet.com/threads/excel-2016-linking-error.30545/post-204024, looks like the settings there worked for someone. Who's asking?

I used 2017, so makes sense. Odd that it did not work for 2015 though

The steps here work for me in VS (substitute xlwings for matplotlib): Python in Visual Studio tutorial step 5, install packages

For Python dev I strongly recommend PyCharm over VS. Among other advantages, package management is much simpler.

There was recent thread about this. It all depends on the role. C++ is far from obsolete.

The primary reason VS is a requirement for the advanced course is that some of the newer C++ features (which are covered in this course) are not fully supported on other compilers. Additionally, some features may differ on other compilers (i.e. the deprecated feature). One option would be to...

OP did not specify that he was specifically looking to get a decision-making role as a pure Quant on a trading desk (for which I concur with you, the vast majority of such roles do not use C++). Many people going for MFE and on this forum are not necessarily looking for such a role; there are...

From my experience and observations across several major firms, I think that blanket statements that C++ is no longer used are absolutely false. It really depends on your role: As Dave mentioned above, Quant roles that are about fast decision making will generally do everything using Python or...

It's worth mentioning that, for hands-on experience of many practical design patterns (among other topics), the QN advanced C++ course is excellent: Advanced C++11/C++14 and Multidisciplinary

It's similar to the pervasive 'tax refund' mentality.

It does not support C++. You'd either need to use a VM (I.e parallels) with VS or use xcode

The latest version is here: Downloads | IDE, Code, & Team Foundation Server | Visual Studio

The details of the exam are sent to you once you submit level 9. In general, it is a 30 minute Skype based exam where the proctor will send you several questions that must be responded to in Skype chat.

I see a similar issue was answered here, does this help?: Visual Studio 2015 curl will not statically link

The QN advanced C++ course covers these, among many other topics: Advanced C++11/C++14 and Multidisciplinary

Web based compilers will not be adequate to properly develop in C++. You'll need a physical compiler. VS is strongly recommended for the course.

See Installing, Uninstalling and Upgrading Packages - Help | PyCharm

I like PyCharm for Python development. It's a visual IDE and has a built-in tool to easily download packages such as numpy or scipy.

Downloads | IDE, Code, & Team Foundation Server | Visual Studio

Yes

The sample video mentions property getters/setters; that is, using the @property decorator. The property decorator is the recommended mechanism in Python to get/set attributes of an object, especially if any post-processing/constraint is needed or if one wishes to 'protect' the attribute for...

Correct Correct See https://www.quantnet.com/posts/?post_id=73017

That shouldn't be, unless there are some hidden files. Maybe try viewing hidden files?

Definitely. Many students have had no previous programming background at all.

Another option is a virtual machine. Also, note that there is an Excel integration piece in Level 9. It's worth about 2/13 of your level 9 grade

It's certainly doable for this course, but may necessitate additional work, especially in levels 8&9. VS is recommended

Assuming you've submitted level 9 and completed quiz 10 prior to your deadline, we offer some leeway for the final exam (I.e, a week or two)

You'll receive a pdf copy within a day or two. The physical copy depends on USPS and where you're located

You will receive detailed feedback and a grade within 24-48 hours of submission; usually quicker, very rarely slower.

See GENERAL - C++ Course Grading Policy The quizzes are not graded - they are a learning tool. The final exam is still a Skype based exam with your TA.

Only your overall weighted grade matters

The details of the exam are sent to you once you submit level 9. The grade policy is here: https://www.quantnet.com/posts/?post_id=73017

Sure, just make sure to enroll around then

1) You work at your own pace within the 16 weeks. 2) Any version 2010 or newer.

https://www.quantnet.com/threads/faq-c-for-financial-engineering-online-course.7376/#post-90019 This assumes the full 16 weeks; it's possible to complete much quicker.

You can use the certificate. If they require something additional, you may contact the Baruch MFE program and they'll provide you with a letter (which includes the grade).

See the first post in this thread regarding the prerequisites for the course. Distinction in the previous course is not a requirement, as long as your knowledge and skills are up to scratch.

See https://www.quantnet.com/posts/?post_id=73017

Yes, of course. Your certificate will contain your real name

Your TA will contact you to work out a time.

Ha, didn't know that was still supported. I last used that on Windows 3.1

Correct. The quizzes on the quiz page are not graded either; they're a learning tool.

Can try clearing you browser cache and restarting.

How to Post Once you've determined that your question has not yet been asked or your topic not yet discussed, you should feel free to post your own question/topic. As there is a vast amount of existing discussion, it is important that we maintain a well-organized forum that is helpful to all...

How to Post Once you've determined that your question has not yet been asked or your topic not yet discussed, you should feel free to post your own question/topic. As there is a vast amount of existing discussion, it is important that we maintain a well-organized forum that is helpful to all...

How to Post Once you've determined that your question has not yet been asked or your topic not yet discussed, you should feel free to post your own question/topic. As there is a vast amount of existing discussion, it is important that we maintain a well-organized forum that is helpful to all...

How to Search Searching the forum is most useful if you have a specific question or error that needs a quick answer. A well-formed search can help you find out if your issue has already been addressed in no time. To search: Click the magnifying glass in the upper-right side of your Quantnet...

How to Search Searching the forum is most useful if you have a specific question or error that needs a quick answer. A well-formed search can help you find out if your issue has already been addressed in no time. To search: Click the magnifying glass in the upper-right side of your Quantnet...

How to Search Searching the forum is most useful if you have a specific question or error that needs a quick answer. A well-formed search can help you find out if your issue has already been addressed in no time. To search: Click the magnifying glass in the upper-right side of your Quantnet...

How to Browse Browsing the forum is the most straightforward way of viewing conversations, questions, and answers regarding the course material. There is a wealth of knowledge already discussed and many questions have already been answered (you just need to find them :)). While browsing can be...

How to Browse Browsing the forum is the most straightforward way of viewing conversations, questions, and answers regarding the course material. There is a wealth of knowledge already discussed and many questions have already been answered (you just need to find them :)). While browsing can be...

How to Browse Browsing the forum is the most straightforward way of viewing conversations, questions, and answers regarding the course material. There is a wealth of knowledge already discussed and many questions have already been answered (you just need to find them :)). While browsing can be...

One of the most powerful and valuable aspects of this C++ course is its public forum. Learning to use the forum effectively may be vital to your success in the course. In general, the following approach should be taken when you have a question or confusion regarding the course material...

One of the most powerful and valuable aspects of this C++ course is its public forum. Learning to use the forum effectively may be vital to your success in the course. In general, the following approach should be taken when you have a question or confusion regarding the course material...

One of the most powerful and valuable aspects of this Python course is its public forum. Learning to use the forum effectively may be vital to your success in the course. In general, the following approach should be taken when you have a question or confusion regarding the course material...

VS is highly recommended for this course. It is an industry standard. You're allowed to use other compilers, but if you encounter compiler specific issues you may not be able to find help as easily. Level 9 in specific may have issues with other compilers. In terms of ease of use, there's...

Yea, let's hope that's not necessary...:eek: You can try to physically remove anything VS related from your file system, but this itself can be risky.

By refresh, I mean a full reinstall of the OS.

Do you run the install as administrator? Also, maybe this can help: Visual Studio Community 2015 update 2 error Pls help - Visual Studio Setup and Installation - www.gittprogram.com Worst case, you may need to install an earlier version of VS, or refresh your PC.

Same errors each time?

Have you tried a complete uninstall/reinstall?

See this discussion: https://www.quantnet.com/threads/can-we-get-a-recommendation-letter-from-this-course.24242/#post-172444

All submissions are graded within 24-48 hours of submission. Usually quicker, rarely slower. Grading is done every day of the week, though weekend grading may be on the higher end of the above timeframe. While there is no guarantee your submission will be graded quicker than the above, it...

The exam time will be arranged offline with your TA, once you've submitted all nine levels. We generally try to accommodate the individual availability of each student (I.e. Weekends if necessary).

Up to several hours.

I'm not going to argue the merits of Python vs. C++ (though I do have strong opinions); I code in both on a daily basis and they both have their practical benefits and shortcomings. However, to imply that Quants don't use C++ nowadays is false. The quants I work with definitely code in C++ (and...

You can put it under Certificates. Note, it is Baruch Pre-MFE. Also, see https://www.quantnet.com/threads/question-about-proof-of-enrollment.23187/#post-166525

That's correct. A bit more detail than the certificate.

Baruch will provide a general letter of completion, upon request. In terms of a separate letter from your TA — that's discretionary and up to your TA to decide on a case by case basis, upon completion. It is likely only to be provided in exceptional cases. It is also worth noting that some MFE...

What's this for? Quantlib is not part of the course

It may come in handy but is definitely not required.

It goes without saying that academic honesty is taken very seriously. Students are expected to submit all original code and documents. See Academic Honesty - Baruch College. This means that students may not collaborate or use others' (current or previous student's) code in any way, other than...

It goes without saying that academic honesty is taken very seriously. Students are expected to submit all original code and documents. See Academic Honesty - Baruch College. This means that students may not collaborate or use others' (current or previous student's) code in any way, other than...

It goes without saying that academic honesty is taken very seriously. Students are expected to submit all original code and documents. This means that students may not collaborate or use others' (current or previous student's) code in any way, other than what is on the public forum. Students may...

Start with debugging allows you to use the VS debugger. Without does not. A solution can technically have multiple projects. Build solution builds them all.

Build=Compile+Link Build all ensures everything gets rebuilt whereas build will only recompile files which have changed. Start with debugging allows you to use the VS debugger

See https://www.quantnet.com/threads/a-question-about-vc-compiling-not-visual-studio.21998/#post-160643 and others. You can set a breakpoint in VS and then use the debug menu to step through by line. This happens at runtime, not at compile time.

1) Create a new project 2) Copy/paste the existing files into the new project's folder in windows explorer 3) Add existing files in solution explorer

@JTRWilliam, Please see my previous response, above, for the solution:

void main is incorrect: https://www.quantnet.com/threads/exercise-1.17500/#post-136644 . You should return 0; Regarding COFF: https://www.quantnet.com/threads/rebuild-failure.16392/#post-130513

What does the compile error say? You are missing a return statement.

That first popup is expected. You should click 'yes'. The second popup is telling you there was a compile error -- there is something incorrect with your code (you should click 'No' since there is no 'last one' yet). You should then check the build screen to see what the error is. You need to...